Negative reviews and defamation: under Italian Supreme Court ruling 38380/2026 there is no right to criticise when a false fact is attributed, but damages must be reassessed after a minor-offence discharge. If you are involved in an online defamation case, our firm can assist you.
Commentary on a judgment of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation. The names of the parties are omitted in the decision.
Writing a negative review on a travel portal is an everyday, almost automatic gesture. But when the criticism attributes to a specific person conduct they never engaged in, a negative review can turn into aggravated defamation, with a criminal conviction and an award of damages. This is the lesson of judgment no. 38380 of the Fifth Criminal Section of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation, filed on 3 November 2026, which addresses two questions of great practical importance: the limits of the right to criticise online, and the effects of non-punishability for minor offences on the amount of damages.
The decision is interesting precisely because it does not fully side with either party. It confirms that the review was defamatory. But it annuls the part of the appeal judgment that had left the damages unchanged.
The case: hotel breakfast and a review targeting an absent manager
In October 2019 a guest had breakfast at a hotel. A few days later he published a negative review on a portal, denouncing the rare rudeness of the staff and, in particular, of the hotel manager. The problem is that, according to the findings of the trial, the manager was not even present that day.
In September 2023 the Court of Rovereto convicted the author of the review of defamation and ordered him to pay the civil party damages of 3,000 euros. In December 2025 the Court of Appeal of Trento reformed the judgment, applying the ground of non-punishability for minor offences under Article 131-bis of the Italian Criminal Code, but fully confirmed the civil rulings, including the amount of damages.
The defendant appealed to the Court of Cassation on three grounds: the failure to assess the reliability of the main prosecution witness, the existence of the right to criticise, and the failure to reassess the damages.
Negative reviews and the right to criticise: no defence without a true fact
Criticism is free, but it must start from a true fact
The right to criticise, rooted in Article 21 of the Italian Constitution and operating as a justification under Article 51 of the Criminal Code, allows even harsh opinions. But case law consistently requires three conditions: the truth of the fact underlying the criticism, restraint in expression, and public interest or social relevance.
The defence argued that the review met the truth requirement in a "not strictly formal" sense: even if the manager was not there, he would still be responsible for his staff's behaviour by virtue of his supervisory position. The Court of Cassation rejected the argument. The criticism was built on an objectively false premise, namely that the manager himself had behaved rudely. Recalling settled precedents of the same Fifth Section, the Court reaffirmed that the right to criticise cannot disregard the truth of the historical fact on which the criticism is based.
Why the distinction matters for anyone writing online reviews
The difference is subtle but decisive. Writing that the service was rude, the breakfast poor or the staff not up to standard is an assessment that generally falls within the scope of criticism. Attributing specific conduct to an identified person, when that conduct did not happen, means introducing a false fact into public discourse. And it is that false fact that turns a negative review into defamation.
It is worth remembering that, under settled case law, defamation committed online falls within the aggravated form of Article 595(3) of the Criminal Code, which punishes offences committed through the press or any other means of publicity. A review portal accessible to anyone falls squarely into this category.
The limits of the Supreme Court's review of witness evidence
On the first ground, the Court recalled that it cannot substitute its own assessment of the evidence for that of the trial judges. The first-instance judge had given detailed reasons on the reliability of the witnesses and had found a defence witness, who emerged only during the trial, not credible, sending the file to the prosecutor to consider a possible charge of false testimony. The Court of Appeal had adopted that reasoning. According to the Court of Cassation, the defendant's complaints actually sought a different reading of the evidence, which is inadmissible at this level.
Minor-offence non-punishability is not an acquittal
The most interesting passage concerns Article 131-bis of the Criminal Code. The Court of Appeal had used the wording "acquits", but the Court of Cassation points out that this is improper. A declaration of non-punishability for minor offences is a form of discharge, but not an acquittal: it establishes that the offence exists and is attributable to the defendant in all its elements, and excludes only punishment.
The Court refers to the 2022 Joint Sections ruling and to judgment no. 173 of 2022 of the Italian Constitutional Court, according to which a minor offence is not punished not because it is harmless, but because the legislature considers it inappropriate to punish it, even though it is a typical, unlawful and culpable act. In the same judgment, the Constitutional Court declared Article 538 of the Code of Criminal Procedure unconstitutional insofar as it did not allow the judge, when discharging for minor offence, to rule on the civil party's claim for damages.
This has important practical consequences: a defendant discharged for minor offence is not "innocent". The finding of fact remains, the possibility of being ordered to pay damages remains, and the decision may be entered in the criminal record.
Negative reviews and damages: the award must be recalculated, even of the court's own motion
The principle
The third ground was upheld. The defence had not raised a specific ground of appeal on the amount of damages, but argued that the judge should still have reassessed it in light of the different assessment of the facts implied by the application of Article 131-bis.
While acknowledging that the issue is complex and tied to the still-debated nature of the institution, the Court of Cassation endorsed the view that a discharge for minor offence contains an assessment of the seriousness of the act capable of affecting the determination of pecuniary or non-pecuniary damage. It follows that an appeal judgment applying the minor-offence rule, since it helps define the defendant's actual responsibility, also affects the amount of compensable damage and requires the judge, by virtue of the devolutive effect of the appeal, to redetermine the sum awarded at first instance, even of its own motion.
The outcome
The Court of Appeal of Trento, which had revised the criminal conviction without touching the 3,000-euro award, should have asked whether that amount needed to be adjusted in light of the new dimension given to the facts. For this reason the Court of Cassation annulled the judgment insofar as it concerned damages, referring the case to the civil court competent by value at appeal level, and dismissed the appeal on all other points.
Critical analysis: what changes for reviewers and for those reviewed
For the author of the review
The first lesson is clear: freedom to review does not cover attributing false facts to specific people. Before publishing a negative review, it is wise to stick to what you personally experienced, avoid naming by name or role anyone who was not involved, and keep the language within the bounds of assessment, without sliding into personal attacks.
The second lesson concerns defence strategy. Minor-offence non-punishability is a useful outcome, but it should not be confused with an acquittal. If obtained on appeal, judgment no. 38380/2026 provides a concrete argument for seeking a reduction of the damages awarded at first instance, even without a specific ground of appeal on the point.
For hoteliers, restaurateurs and professionals who are reviewed
On the other side, the judgment confirms that the target of a false review has effective tools: a criminal complaint for aggravated defamation and joining the criminal proceedings as a civil party, or alternatively a civil action for damages. In Italy the deadline for filing a complaint is three months from knowledge of the facts, and it is essential to preserve evidence of the review, with date, URL and content, before it is edited or removed.
An issue still open
The Court of Cassation itself notes that the issue is evolving: by an order filed on 29 July 2026, the Joint Sections referred to the Constitutional Court a question on the lack of remedies against a discharge for minor offence in crimes punishable by alternative penalties. Defamation is one of those crimes. Developments are worth following, as they could directly affect defence strategies in online defamation trials.
Legal assistance for online defamation and negative reviews
Our firm assists both those accused of defamation for a review, post or online comment and those who are its victims: from the preliminary assessment of the content to the criminal complaint, from defence in criminal proceedings to appeals against civil rulings, up to the Court of Cassation.
If you have received a legal document concerning a review or content published online, or believe you have been defamed and want to assess how to protect yourself, fill in the form at the bottom of the page: one of our lawyers will review the documents and contact you.
Do you need legal assistance?
Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.
