YouTube like scam on Telegram: an Italian Justice of the Peace ordered the holder of one of the receiving accounts to return the money with interest. If you lost money in a similar scam, our firm can assist you.
Case handled by our firm. The personal data of the parties have been anonymised.
The YouTube like scam almost always starts the same way: a WhatsApp message from a foreign number, an invitation to "like" a few videos in exchange for a few euros, a first real payment that serves to win trust. Then the move to Telegram, the paid "tasks", the orders to complete on a fake online shopping centre, the refunds that never arrive and, finally, the fake recovery agents who ask for more money to "unlock" what has already been lost.
The case we describe is one of these. It ended with a judgment worth reading carefully: the Justice of the Peace of Bari ordered the holder of one of the accounts that received the victim's transfers to return the sums received, with interest from the day of collection and legal costs. Without waiting for the outcome of the criminal investigation and without having to identify the authors of the fraud.
How the YouTube like scam works: from a "like" to a request for 15,000 euros
The WhatsApp hook and the first real payments
In June 2024 our client, a young professional from the province of Bari, was added to a WhatsApp group chat by a number with a British prefix. The offer was simple: like some videos published on YouTube and receive a small fee in return. The first payment, of about three euros, really arrived. This is the step that makes everything else credible: someone who has received real money rarely suspects fraud.
The move to Telegram and the fake online shopping centre
Immediately afterwards, the victim was moved to a Telegram channel. Here the "tasks" changed nature: to continue, he had to complete orders on a so-called online shopping centre called Supermazdu.com, paying in capital that would be returned with a bonus of about 20%. The first payment, of 1,620 euros, was not refunded: a second order was needed. Then a third. Then the opening of a "VIP refund channel" costing 15,000 euros, payable in two instalments.
Within a few days, at the end of June 2024, the victim transferred more than 20,000 euros to a single account held by a limited liability company. It is the same pattern described in our analysis of the fake online job scam.
The second wave: fake recovery agents, "points" and fake legal trouble
When the victim stopped paying, the scam did not end: it changed face. In August 2024 a Telegram proposal arrived to "unlock" the entire amount paid by paying a percentage. Then a so-called mentor directed the victim to an administrator who would manage the refund on a second website, Amazonicoin.it. Increasingly imaginative requests followed: 10% of the capital to unlock the account, the purchase of missing "points" at 200 euros each, even payments to avoid alleged legal consequences linked to an "advance" received. Each payment went to a different account, held by a different name.
In the end, the total loss exceeded 40,000 euros, spread over more than ten IBANs, almost all postal or payment-institution accounts. This is the typical dynamic of the fake recovery scam, which targets people who have already been defrauded once.
YouTube like scam: why a criminal complaint alone does not return the money
The victim, assisted by our firm, filed a criminal complaint with the Carabinieri for computer fraud. It is an essential step, but it must be said frankly: in YouTube like scams the organisers operate from foreign numbers and Telegram channels, and identifying them is often slow and uncertain. Investigations against unknown persons may end with a request to dismiss the case, which can still be opposed.
There is, however, an objective fact that does not depend on identifying the fraudsters: the money was credited to Italian accounts held by identifiable individuals and companies. That is where action can start.
The first step: finding out who is behind each IBAN
The name of the beneficiary of a transfer does not always match the one given by the fraudster. In our case, the holder of one of the accounts was identified through the payment institution where the account was opened, following formal requests sent by counsel. Knowing the real holder of each IBAN is the precondition for any civil action: without a defendant, there is no case.
Two civil tracks: precautionary attachment and recovery of undue payment
The strategy followed two directions, calibrated on the amount transferred to each beneficiary.
Precautionary attachment against the company that received over 20,000 euros
For the company account that received three transfers totalling 20,580 euros, we asked the Court of Bari for a precautionary attachment of receivables held by third parties under Article 671 of the Italian Code of Civil Procedure. The judge authorised it up to 26,000 euros, including interest and costs, finding the risk of loss proven by a series of indicators: share capital of a few thousand euros, certified email address unable to receive, registered office unknown, no real estate, failed recall of the transfers, account found empty. We described this tool in another case of precautionary attachment to recover money lost to an online scam.
The claim before the Justice of the Peace for smaller amounts
For smaller amounts, the competent court is the Justice of the Peace: Article 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure gives it jurisdiction over claims concerning movable property up to 10,000 euros, and the extension of that jurisdiction up to 30,000 euros has been postponed to 31 October 2027. This choice should not be underestimated: a simpler procedure, often faster, with costs proportionate to the value of the dispute.
Before acting, our client sent a formal demand to the account holder and invited her to assisted negotiation, which in Italy is a precondition for court claims for payment of sums up to 50,000 euros. The invitation went unanswered.
The judgment: what the Justice of the Peace of Bari decided
With a judgment dated 8 November 2026, the Justice of the Peace of Bari fully upheld the claim for recovery of undue payment brought under Article 2033 of the Italian Civil Code against the holder of the postal account to which the victim had made two transfers, of 600 and 500 euros, in September 2024. The defendant, duly summoned, did not appear.
The burden of proof in an action for objective undue payment
The judge recalled the case law of the Italian Supreme Court, most recently confirmed by judgment no. 21340 of 2025, according to which whoever acts under Article 2033 must prove both the payment and the absence of any cause justifying it. In our case the claimant documented the transfers, the ownership of the receiving account and the absence of any relationship with the beneficiary. Faced with this evidence, it was for the defendant to prove a valid reason for the payment: she did not do so.
Fraud established incidentally in civil proceedings
Particularly significant is the passage in which the judge, assessing all the documents produced, found that the claimant had been the victim of computer fraud: the payments had been induced by deception, in the belief that he was carrying out financial transactions. No criminal judgment was needed to reach this conclusion: a complete and orderly set of documents was enough, consisting of the criminal complaint, transfer receipts, chats and a reconstruction of the steps.
Bad faith and interest from the day of collection
Article 2033 draws a distinction: if the recipient was in good faith, interest runs from the claim; if in bad faith, from the day of payment. The Justice of the Peace found that the account holder acted in bad faith and awarded interest from the moment of the unlawful collection. The defendant was also ordered to pay the costs of the assisted negotiation and of the proceedings.
Critical analysis: the limits of this route and why it remains the most practical
It would be wrong to present this judgment as the solution to every YouTube like scam. It has precise limits that must be known.
The first is fragmentation. When transfers are spread over ten or more accounts, each holder is a separate defendant, with separate proceedings. It must be assessed case by case, based on the amounts, whether to act against all, some, or concentrate resources where recovery is most likely.
The second is enforcement. A judgment against a holder who has emptied the account and has no assets risks remaining on paper. That is why, where the amount justifies it, precautionary attachment must be requested immediately, before the money disappears.
The third is the relationship with criminal proceedings. A civil action for undue payment does not exclude joining the criminal trial as a civil party if the account holders are indicted for fraud or money laundering; the two routes can reinforce each other, but they must be coordinated to avoid duplication.
The essential point remains: whoever lends their account to receive money of unlawful origin cannot simply stay absent from the proceedings and count on impunity. The civil court can order them to repay, with interest and costs, on the basis of well-built documentary evidence.
What to do immediately after a YouTube like or Telegram scam
The first hours and days are decisive. The priority actions are:
- stop any payment, even if it is presented as the "last" one or as a condition to unlock funds;
- immediately ask your bank to recall the transfers, keeping its reply;
- save WhatsApp and Telegram chats, phone numbers, usernames, screenshots of the websites and receipts of every payment;
- file a complete criminal complaint, listing all IBANs, holders and amounts;
- have the real holder of each account identified and assess with a lawyer precautionary attachment, payment order or an action for recovery of undue payment, depending on the amounts;
- ignore anyone who contacts the victim promising to recover the money in return for upfront fees.
No one can guarantee full recovery of the sums. But every Italian account through which the money passed is a concrete point of leverage that a well-designed legal strategy can use.
Legal assistance for victims of the YouTube like scam
Our firm assists victims of online scams linked to fake jobs, Telegram tasks and paid likes: from the criminal complaint to identifying account holders, from precautionary attachment to actions for recovery of undue payment before the Justice of the Peace and the Court.
If you made transfers after an earning proposal linked to likes, reviews or online orders and want to understand which actions are available in your case, fill in the form at the bottom of the page: one of our lawyers will review the documents and contact you.
Do you need legal assistance?
Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.
