AvvocatoPenalista H24
← Blog

Legal guides

Self-defence: why Italy's Supreme Court ruled it out for the jeweller who shot fleeing robbers

20 November 2026 · Avvocato Penalista H24

With judgment no. 590/2026 the Italian Court of Cassation made final the conviction of the jeweller from Grinzane Cavour: the robbery was over, the danger had ended. Here are the limits of self-defence. If you are involved in proceedings for a violent crime in Italy, contact us: we are available 24/7.

Four pistol shots fired within seconds, at the back of a jewellery shop, while the robbers were getting into a car to flee. Two dead, one wounded. With judgment no. 590 of 15 July 2026, whose reasons were filed in November, the First Criminal Section of the Italian Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal of the jeweller from Grinzane Cavour and made final his sentence of 14 years and 9 months for murder, attempted murder and illegally carrying a weapon. The core of the decision is one point: it was not self-defence.

The case has divided Italian public opinion like few others. That is exactly why it deserves a technical reading, far from slogans: the Supreme Court's reasons do not say that a robbery victim cannot defend themselves, but they draw a precise line between defence and reaction once the danger is over.

Self-defence ruled out: the facts captured by the cameras

The reconstruction, shared by the Asti Assize Court and the Turin Assize Court of Appeal, rests largely on surveillance footage analysed second by second.

On 28 April 2021 three men, masked and armed with a knife and a pistol later found to be a toy, carried out a violent robbery in the shop, threatening the owner, his wife and his daughter. Having taken the jewels, they left through the back door. At the very moment the outside cameras filmed them outside the shop, the inside camera showed the owner opening the till drawer and taking out a revolver. Four seconds later he was at the back door, while the robbers were about to get into the car.

The shots followed in rapid succession: the first at the driver's seat, then at the other two, hit from the side and from behind while bending to get into the car, and finally a shot inside the vehicle. Two robbers died; the third, wounded in the knee, managed to flee on foot. Immediately afterwards, the jeweller himself called 112.

On this basis the trial courts ruled out the justification in every form: actual, putative and excessive. The Court of Cassation confirmed.

The requirements of self-defence according to the Court of Cassation

The judgment restates settled case law: self-defence (Article 52 of the Italian Criminal Code) requires an unjust aggression and a legitimate reaction. The first must amount to a current danger of harm that, if not neutralised immediately, would result in the violation of a right; the second requires that the danger be unavoidable, that defence be necessary and that it be proportionate to the harm.

Two corollaries follow, which the Court expressly recalls. A reaction is not justified when the harmful action is already over. And using means that are not the only ones available is not lawful, because they could be replaced by others equally effective and less harmful to the aggressor. In other words, the reaction must be necessary and have no alternatives at the moment it occurs.

In this case, the danger to the life and safety of the owner and his family had ended: the robbery was over, the loot already taken, the robbers about to flee. The Supreme Court calls purely hypothetical, with no factual basis, the possibility that they would come back to attack those still in the shop.

Self-defence at home after the 2019 reform: what "always" really means

The most delicate issue concerns self-defence in the home, governed by paragraphs two, three and four of Article 52 and strengthened by Law no. 36 of 26 April 2019. The provision states that, at home and in equivalent places such as a business, using a lawfully held weapon against someone who has unlawfully entered is "always" proportionate.

Citing its own 2020 precedent, the Court clarifies the scope of that adverb. "Always" does not create an absolute presumption that armed defence is lawful: it only strengthens the presumption of proportionality already introduced by the 2006 reform. The other requirements remain intact and must be checked case by case:

  • the danger of harm must be current;
  • using the weapon must be necessary to protect one's own or others' safety, or the property present;
  • no lawful or less harmful alternatives must be available;
  • for attacks on property, there must also be a danger of personal aggression.

Even at home, therefore, the justification does not apply if the violent conduct is not ongoing or concretely imminent. The Court cites a similar case in which self-defence was excluded for a shopkeeper who, having discovered a break-in, came down armed and fired at the intruders' car and at the person leaving the premises.

One detail matters: the Court found it unnecessary to decide whether the outside area where the shots were fired, a space open to the public belonging to another building, fell within the places protected by Article 52. Even if it did, the danger was not current.

The lawful alternative: lock the doors and call the police

One passage of the reasons deserves particular attention, because it shifts the focus from theory to practice. The trial judges did not merely deny the danger: they identified the lawful alternative the owner could have adopted. It would have been enough for him and his family to lock the shop's entrances and alert the police.

It is a criterion that applies to anyone in a similar situation. Self-defence does not authorise chasing or capturing the offender with weapons: it authorises the reaction strictly necessary to neutralise an ongoing aggression. When the choice is between getting to safety and giving chase, the law clearly points to the former.

Putative self-defence: the mistake must rest on concrete facts, not fear

The defence relied on putative self-defence (Article 59 of the Criminal Code): even if the danger was over, the jeweller allegedly believed, by mistake, that it still existed. In particular, he feared that his wife had been taken hostage and reacted on seeing a robber point the toy pistol at him.

The Court recalls that the requirements of putative self-defence are identical to those of actual self-defence, with one difference: the danger does not exist objectively but is assumed by the person because of a mistaken assessment of the facts. That mistake, however, must be justified by concrete facts capable of creating a reasonable belief of being in danger. Fear or the person's state of mind alone is not enough. And the assessment must be made ex ante, at the moment of the reaction, not with hindsight.

In this case both defence arguments were contradicted by the footage. The inside cameras showed the owner bumping into his wife, gun in hand, and moving her aside to get out: he could not have believed she had been kidnapped. As for the robber with the toy gun, the footage showed him leaving the shop without pointing it at anyone, and he was shot while getting into the car. Even expert assessments of the jeweller's emotional state were not considered sufficient: a declared defensive intent, without factual support, does not establish the justification.

Excessive self-defence and "serious distress": why they are not enough

The last line of defence was excessive self-defence (Article 55 of the Criminal Code) and the ground for non-punishment introduced in 2019 for those acting in a state of serious distress caused by an ongoing dangerous situation (Article 55, paragraph two).

Here too the Court's answer is clear. Excessive self-defence presupposes that the requirements of self-defence, actual or putative, exist and that the person negligently exceeds their limits, for example by miscalculating the danger or the means of defence. If there is no dangerous situation, there is no limit to exceed. Likewise, serious distress is relevant only if it is caused by a concrete situation of serious danger in progress, not by states of mind with pre-existing or different causes.

In the case examined, the judges found a voluntary and conscious choice: a deliberate aggression not justified by the need to defend oneself. This reading was reinforced by what happened after the shots, including chasing the wounded with the gun in hand, and by the defendant's own statements in interviews, in which he described his action as the only way to stop the robbers and bring them to justice. For the Court, his purpose was to take justice into his own hands.

Owning a gun does not mean you can carry it in the street

The judgment also confirms the conviction for illegally carrying the revolver. The defence argued that, since the weapon was lawfully held, there was no offence. But the Italian public security law clearly distinguishes the two situations: holding a weapon requires reporting it to the public security authority, while carrying it outside one's home or shop requires a specific licence. Going out into the street gun in hand, without a carrying licence, is a separate offence.

The other issues: lay judges, statements and mitigating circumstances

The appeal raised sixteen grounds, many of them procedural: the replacement of a lay judge absent at the last hearing, the admissibility of statements made by the jeweller in the hours after the events, his mental capacity and the calculation of the sentence. The Court dismissed them or declared them inadmissible.

On sentencing, the Court noted that the mitigating circumstance of provocation had been granted to the maximum extent, and that general mitigating circumstances had been applied more modestly, partly because of the lack of remorse and the conduct after the offence. The constitutional question on the provisional damages awarded to the civil parties was also declared inadmissible.

What the judgment teaches robbery victims

The reasons offer some clear lessons that go well beyond this case:

  • Timing is decisive: self-defence covers the reaction to an ongoing or imminent aggression, not to a robbery that has already ended.
  • The aggressor's flight closes the window for defence: chasing someone who is running away turns defence into offence.
  • The 2019 reform is not a licence to shoot: "always proportionate" concerns only proportionality, while urgency, necessity and lack of alternatives remain requirements to be proven.
  • Cameras are the first witness: in this trial, the second-by-second timeline decided the outcome.
  • What you say afterwards matters: interviews and public statements can be used by judges to reconstruct real intentions.

Need assistance in a self-defence case or a violent crime case? Contact our firm

Whether you are under investigation for reacting to an aggression or the victim of a violent crime, the first hours and the first statements can decide the outcome of the proceedings. Our firm assists clients at every stage of Italian criminal proceedings, from the investigation to the appeal before the Court of Cassation, with 24-hour availability.

Fill in the form at the bottom of the page: briefly describe your situation and we will contact you to assess your case.

Free case review

Do you need legal assistance?

Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.

If you lost less than €5000 we cannot proceed · full confidentiality · no obligation.
Available now · 24 hours a day

Tell us about your case.
A lawyer replies — not a call centre.

Fill in the form: a lawyer from our firm assesses your case free of charge and tells you right away how we can help. Day or night, weekends included.