AvvocatoPenalista H24
← Blog

Insight

Money mules must pay back: the Court of Florence orders account holders to return 34,000 euros, even in good faith

15 November 2026 · Avvocato Penalista H24

Two Court of Florence judgments obtained by our firm: whoever lent their account to scammers must return everything, even in good faith. If your money ended up in a money mule's account, we can help you recover it.

Case handled by our firm. The personal data of the parties have been anonymised.

Lending your bank account to strangers to "process payments" in exchange for a small percentage does not make you a mere bystander to a scam. In two judgments, delivered on 14 July and 2 November 2026, the Court of Florence ordered two money mules, that is, the holders of the accounts into which our client's transfers had been paid, to return a total of 34,000 euros to her. In one of the two cases the account holder argued that she herself had been deceived by a fake job advertisement and had kept only 610 euros. That was not enough.

The two decisions clarify a point every scam victim should know: to recover money from the account holder, you do not need to prove that they were an accomplice. Good faith only affects interest.

The scam: the k.ecosforai.com platform and over 163,000 euros wired to strangers

Between October and December 2024 our client fell victim to a fake online trading scam. Believing she was investing through a platform called k.ecosforai.com, which turned out not to exist, she made a long series of transfers to Italian bank accounts held by people she did not know, using the payment references dictated by the fraudsters, for a total of more than 163,000 euros. Every time she tried to withdraw her capital, she was asked to pay more: the pattern we describe in our guide on the broker that will not let you withdraw.

After the criminal complaint, our firm reconstructed the money flows and identified the holders of the destination accounts. For each of them we followed the same path: formal demand, invitation to assisted negotiation, and a civil claim for the recovery of an undue payment under Article 2033 of the Italian Civil Code.

Who the money mule is: a Facebook job ad and a 2-3% fee

The defence of one of the account holders is a textbook portrait of the modern money mule. She had answered a job advertisement on Facebook promising quick earnings. She was asked to open an account with an online bank, through which a so-called sales company would route its customers' payments. The task was simple: receive the money and immediately forward it by instant transfer to another account, keeping 2 to 3% as a fee.

That is how she received our client's 20,000 euros, in two transfers on the same day, and forwarded 19,390 of them, keeping 610. In December 2024 she closed the account and cut off all contact with the recruiter.

It is the same mechanism we analysed from a criminal-law perspective in our article on money laundering by money mules and the proof of eventual intent. The Florence judgments, however, concern civil law, where the rules are different.

Money mules and Article 2033 of the Civil Code: why the account holder must return everything

The burden of proof for undue payment

In both cases the Court applied the settled principles of the Italian Supreme Court on undue payment: the claimant must prove the payment and allege the absence of any legal ground for it; it is up to the defendant to prove a valid title to keep the money. The action, one of the judgments specifies, is objective in nature: it restores the balance upset by a transfer of wealth without cause, regardless of the payer's mistake or intent.

Our client produced the transfer receipts. The defendants did not point to any relationship with her, no contract and no debt. In one case the account holder admitted she had never met her. That was enough.

The Article 2038 issue: money is not a "thing" that has been sold on

The most insidious defence relied on Article 2038 of the Civil Code. The account holder claimed she had received the money in good faith and "transferred" it to others before learning she had to return it, so she should only give back what she had obtained, namely the 610 euros she kept.

The Court of Florence rejected the argument firmly. Article 2038 concerns the sale of a specific movable item with its own individual identity, and governs its acquisition by a third party. Money is a fungible asset and falls outside that provision. Anyone who receives a sum without title and passes it on cannot rely on that rule to limit the obligation to the fee they kept. They must return the full amount received.

This is the core of the decision, and its practical importance is huge: had the opposite view prevailed, any money mule could walk away by returning 1 or 2% of what passed through their account.

Good faith only matters for interest

Good or bad faith is not irrelevant, however. Under Article 2033, interest runs from the day of payment if the recipient acted in bad faith, and from the date of the claim if in good faith. Both judgments restate, following the Supreme Court, that good faith is presumed and bad faith must be proven: it must be shown that the recipient knew, at the time of receipt, that they had no right to the money.

In one case the Court held that the recruitment methods documented in the chats and the later closure of the account ruled out such awareness. In the other, it stated that being heard as a person informed of the facts in the criminal proceedings implies no finding of involvement in the scam. In both cases interest was awarded from the date of the claim. That affects the final amount, not the right to restitution.

The procedural choices that sped up recovery

The payment order during the proceedings

In the first case the defendant asked for the civil proceedings to be stayed pending the criminal case, under Article 295 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court refused, noting that no criminal proceedings on those facts were pending and that there was no preliminary link requiring a stay. In the same order, issued in December 2025, it granted our application under Article 186-ter of the Code of Civil Procedure, ordering the defendant to pay back 14,000 euros straight away: an enforceable title obtained months before the judgment, usable without waiting for the end of the case.

Simplified procedure, mediation and assisted negotiation

The second case was brought under the simplified procedure and decided by a judgment delivered at the hearing under Article 281-sexies of the Code of Civil Procedure. The judge had ordered court-referred mediation, which failed, and then also charged the mediation costs to the defendant. In the first case, the failure to respond to the invitation to assisted negotiation was taken into account for costs, though it did not justify a penalty for vexatious litigation.

These are technical details, but they make the difference between a recovery that arrives in reasonable time and one that drags on for years. We have also discussed them in the case of the YouTube likes scam before the Justice of the Peace and in the case of recovery of an undue payment from the company holding the account.

Critical analysis: an effective weapon, with limits worth knowing

The two Florence judgments confirm that civil action against account holders is today the most concrete tool to recover at least part of the money lost in an online scam. It does not depend on identifying the organisers, who often operate abroad, and it does not require waiting for the outcome of the criminal trial.

The limits must be stated clearly, though. The first is solvency: a judgment against a money mule with no income or assets can be hard to enforce. The second is fragmentation: with dozens of destination accounts, you need to choose where to focus, weighing amounts and recovery prospects. The third is time: every case has its own duration, which is why tools such as the Article 186-ter order or a precautionary attachment should be assessed from the outset.

There is also a message for anyone offered a job that involves "processing" money through their own account: even assuming good faith, the risk is twofold. In civil law you are liable for the whole amount received, not just the percentage you kept. In criminal law you risk a money-laundering charge or complicity in fraud.

What to do if your money ended up in a money mule's account

The priority steps are:

  • gather all transfer receipts and bank statements, with IBANs and beneficiary names;
  • file a complete criminal complaint, listing every destination account;
  • have the beneficial owner of each account identified and their solvency checked;
  • send a formal demand and an invitation to assisted negotiation, which is also a precondition for payment claims up to 50,000 euros;
  • assess with a lawyer the undue-payment claim, precautionary attachment and applications for early payment orders during the case;
  • be wary of anyone promising full recovery in exchange for an upfront fee.

Nobody can guarantee the recovery of every euro. But every Italian account the money passed through is a concrete point of leverage.

Legal assistance against money mules and for the recovery of funds

Our firm assists online scam victims in recovering the money they transferred: from tracing the flows to identifying account holders, from assisted negotiation to undue-payment claims before the Justice of the Peace and the Court, through to precautionary attachment and enforcement.

If you made transfers to strangers' accounts on the instructions of an investment platform or a self-styled advisor and want to know whether you can act against the account holders, fill in the form at the bottom of this page: one of our lawyers will review your documents and get back to you.

Free case review

Do you need legal assistance?

Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.

If you lost less than €5000 we cannot proceed · full confidentiality · no obligation.
Available now · 24 hours a day

Tell us about your case.
A lawyer replies — not a call centre.

Fill in the form: a lawyer from our firm assesses your case free of charge and tells you right away how we can help. Day or night, weekends included.