AvvocatoPenalista H24
← Blog

Insight

Online tractor scam: 31 defendants in Crotone, four criminal associations and our client's civil-party claim

15 November 2026 · Avvocato Penalista H24

A tractor never delivered, 3,100 euros wired and a trial with 31 defendants in Crotone: we have joined the proceedings as civil party for our client. If you are the victim of an online scam, we can assist you in the criminal trial.

Case handled by our firm. The personal data of the parties have been anonymised.

A farm tractor for sale on Facebook Marketplace, an attractive price, a friendly seller on the phone who introduces himself as the manager of a real company. Two transfers of 1,550 euros, then silence. This is the online tractor scam suffered by our client at the end of January 2025, and it was not an isolated case. With the indictment request filed in October 2026, the Public Prosecutor's Office of Crotone has asked for 31 defendants to stand trial, charged variously with aggravated fraud, money laundering, self-laundering, impersonation and with having set up four separate criminal associations specialised in online scams.

For this online tractor scam our firm has filed our client's civil-party application before the preliminary hearing judge of the Court of Crotone. Here is what emerges from the file, and why choosing to take part in the criminal trial is no minor detail for an online scam victim.

How the online tractor scam works: fake ads, dedicated phones and front-man accounts

The indictment request runs to 125 pages and describes a mechanism repeated with industrial precision. There are more than one hundred individual fraud counts. Adding up the amounts listed as unjust profit gives roughly 275,000 euros, with victims living all over Italy and abroad.

The pattern of the online tractor scam is always the same:

  • a sale ad published on websites specialising in farm and construction machinery, on general classified platforms or on Facebook Marketplace;
  • an item that, as every count specifies, the seller never owned: mostly mini excavators and tractors, but also vintage scooters, above-ground pools, skid steers, log splitters and rotary tillers;
  • negotiations by phone through dedicated numbers, often recurring from one episode to the next;
  • payment by bank transfer, sometimes split between two different accounts held by people who have nothing to do with the sale;
  • a seller who vanishes once the money has arrived.

In our client's case, according to the charge, the online tractor scam started with an offer for a farm tractor posted on Facebook Marketplace. The price was paid in two transfers of 1,550 euros, on 27 and 29 January 2025, to two different accounts: one with a bank and the other with Poste Italiane. Total: 3,100 euros. The tractor never arrived.

The fake seller posing as a real company

One element makes these schemes particularly insidious. For some of the episodes, including our client's, the prosecutor also charges impersonation (Article 494 of the Italian Criminal Code): the defendants allegedly introduced themselves to victims as managers of a genuine Milan-based company that had nothing to do with the scam. Anyone checking the company name found real results. The company's legal representative is listed among the victims.

That is why the usual advice, such as "check that the seller exists", is no longer enough: the identity was real, the seller was not.

From fraud to money laundering: the role of money mules

The second half of the scheme concerns the money. The prosecution draws a sharp line between those who organised the scams and those who lent their accounts.

For the account holders, the so-called money mules, the charge is money laundering under Article 648-bis: they allegedly withdrew the freshly credited sums in cash, in several consecutive operations, and handed them to the organisers in exchange for a fee, sometimes as little as 100 euros. The cash withdrawal is what breaks the money trail and, according to the prosecution, amounts to a substitution capable of concealing the criminal origin of the funds.

For those who actually controlled accounts held in other people's names and moved money between them, the charge is self-laundering (Article 648-ter.1): whoever commits the fraud and then reinvests or transfers the proceeds so as to conceal their origin commits a separate offence.

Whether the money mule knew where the money came from will be one of the key issues at trial. We analysed it in our article on money laundering and the proof of eventual intent. Under civil law, however, the account holder must return the money even in good faith, as the Court of Florence has just ruled in another of our cases on money mules having to pay back.

Four criminal associations: why it matters to the victim

The most significant part of the indictment request is the charge of four separate criminal associations under Article 416 of the Criminal Code, each with leaders and promoters, who devised the strategy, recruited front men and ran the phones, and members, who opened accounts, companies and websites and, when needed, collected the proceeds in person. In one case the prosecutor also charges one of the leaders with the aggravating circumstance of having acted while on probation.

This is not an abstract legal label. For the victim, the association widens the circle of people who can be held liable. In our client's case, the count for the individual fraud concerns a single defendant, acting with an unidentified accomplice. But one of the two transfers ended up in the account of a person described as a member of the association linked to the scam. And the prosecutor expressly ties the target offences to that association.

The civil-party application: who we have called to account and why

Who the civil claim is brought against

A civil-party application (Articles 74 et seq. of the Code of Criminal Procedure) allows the victim to claim, within the criminal trial, restitution and compensation for the harm caused by the offence, under Article 185 of the Criminal Code. In our case the claim was brought:

  • against the defendant directly charged with the fraud;
  • against all four defendants of the linked criminal association, including the holder of the account that received one of the transfers.

The legal basis is the causal role of the organised structure in producing the harm. The Italian Supreme Court (civil section III, judgment no. 4908 of 15 February 2022) has recognised the civil liability of members of a criminal association for damage resulting from the target offences attributable to the organisation. Hence the request for joint and several liability under Article 2055 of the Civil Code: the victim can claim the full amount from each of those responsible.

The practical benefit is obvious. More jointly liable parties mean more assets to enforce against. In proceedings with dozens of defendants and hundreds of thousands of euros taken, that makes the difference between a useful judgment and a victory on paper.

What is claimed: restitution, moral damage and an interim payment

The claim covers the financial loss, i.e. the 3,100 euros paid, with revaluation and interest, and non-pecuniary damage for the distress caused by the deception (Article 2059 of the Civil Code), to be assessed on an equitable basis.

We also asked, in the event of a generic award, for an immediately enforceable interim payment under Articles 539(2) and 540(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, equal to the amount of the fraud. It allows the victim to obtain a sum straight away, without waiting for the final assessment of damages in separate civil proceedings.

The deadline not to miss

The notice setting the preliminary hearing reminds victims that the civil-party application must be filed, on pain of forfeiture, at the preliminary hearing, before the checks on the constitution of the parties are completed (Article 79). Missing that moment does not extinguish the right to compensation, but it means losing the chance to pursue it in the criminal trial, leaving only a separate civil action.

There is another often overlooked point: if the defendants ask for the abbreviated procedure, a civil party already in the proceedings can choose whether to accept it. If it does not, it can move the claim to the civil courts without the civil case being stayed. This too is a strategic choice to be assessed case by case.

Critical analysis: a big trial, a small victim

Investigations into the online tractor scam and other serial frauds share a paradox. The bigger they are, the more the individual victim risks becoming invisible. Among more than a hundred episodes, a 3,100-euro loss may seem marginal, and many victims, because of costs or distrust, choose not to join the proceedings. It is an understandable choice, but it should be an informed one.

Three factors led us to advise our client to join:

  • the aggravated nature of the fraud: the prosecutor charges the aggravating circumstance of exploiting the victim's reduced ability to defend himself (Article 61(5)), linked to distance selling, which makes the offence prosecutable ex officio and more severely punished. The trial will go ahead regardless;
  • the asset measures already taken: the file shows a precautionary seizure by equivalent ordered in March 2026 and a personal precautionary measures order of May 2026. For money laundering and self-laundering, Article 648-quater provides for confiscation by equivalent, and frozen assets are a factor to watch for future compensation of victims;
  • the number of jointly liable parties, which concretely widens the chances of recovery.

There is a limit that must be stated honestly: no judgment in itself guarantees recovery, which depends on the solvency of those convicted and the outcome of asset measures. But without a civil-party application, the criminal trial ends without the judge ruling on the victim's loss. We explain this further in our article on why victims should aim for the trial.

How to protect yourself from an online tractor scam before and after paying

Before paying, some warning signs recurring in the Crotone file should put you on alert:

  • a price well below the market value for used farm or construction machinery;
  • no way to see the vehicle in person or pay on delivery;
  • a request to split the payment between two different accounts;
  • accounts held by individuals other than the company the seller claims to represent.

After paying, the priority steps are:

  • immediately file a detailed criminal complaint, attaching the ad, chats, phone numbers and transfer receipts;
  • ask your bank to recall the transfer;
  • keep every piece of evidence, because in cases with dozens of victims investigators cross-check phone numbers and accounts across episodes;
  • follow the proceedings and prepare in good time for the civil-party application, even when the notice arrives almost two years after the events, as in this case.

An example of how an online fraud investigation can continue at the victim's initiative is our case before the Brindisi preliminary investigations judge.

Legal assistance for online scam victims in criminal proceedings

Our firm assists online scam victims at every stage: from the criminal complaint to opposing dismissal, from the civil-party application to the request for an interim payment, through to civil actions against account holders and enforcement of judgments.

If you bought farm machinery, a vehicle or any other item online and never received it, or you have been notified of criminal proceedings in which you are named as a victim, fill in the form at the bottom of this page: one of our lawyers will review your position and get back to you.

Free case review

Do you need legal assistance?

Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.

If you lost less than €5000 we cannot proceed · full confidentiality · no obligation.
Available now · 24 hours a day

Tell us about your case.
A lawyer replies — not a call centre.

Fill in the form: a lawyer from our firm assesses your case free of charge and tells you right away how we can help. Day or night, weekends included.