A fake crypto broker and over 34,000 euros wired to a stranger's accounts: after suing before the Court of Torre Annunziata we obtained a 20,000-euro settlement. If you want to recover money lost to an online scam, we can help.
Case handled by our firm. The personal data of the parties have been anonymised.
Not every lawsuit to recover money lost to an online scam ends with a judgment. Sometimes the fastest route is a settlement, provided it is well drafted. That is what happened to our client, the victim of a fake crypto broker calling itself "FIL Investment Management". After suing, before the Court of Torre Annunziata, the holder of the accounts into which her transfers had been paid and his wife, joint holder of one of the accounts, on 3 November 2026 we signed a settlement: 20,000 euros in four instalments by February 2027, with a clause allowing her to resume the claim for the full amount if any payment is missed.
Here is how we got there, what the agreement provides and which critical points should be weighed before settling with whoever received the scam money.
The scam: a fake crypto manager imitating a major international group
In spring 2025 our client was contacted by self-styled brokers offering crypto investments on behalf of a company called "Fil Investment Management", with a website whose name was designed to imitate that of a well-known international asset management group. The group itself and some foreign regulators had already issued warnings about the misuse of its brand by fraudsters.
It was the classic fake trading pattern: a platform showing growing profits, constant calls from so-called advisors, requests for more deposits and, when it came to withdrawing, obstacles of every kind. We describe it in our guide on the broker that will not let you withdraw.
The fraudsters used two payment channels. Part of the money was routed to a foreign account opened in the victim's name using her documents, from which it was converted into crypto and sent to wallets they controlled. Another part, over 34,000 euros, was wired to two Italian accounts held by a person the victim had never met.
Who the account holder was: the "crypto converter" recruited by phone
The account holder gave his version, later recorded in the recitals of the settlement. In December 2024 he had been called by a so-called representative of the same "FIL Investment Management", who offered him a collaboration: receive the company's clients' investments in his own account, convert them into crypto and load them onto designated platforms. He had checked the company register for a company of that name and, convinced the offer was genuine, signed an affiliation agreement.
This is the typical profile of the new-generation money mule: not merely lending an account, but personally carrying out the conversion into crypto, the last step that makes the money almost impossible to trace. According to his defence, he never had contact with the investors and acted in complete good faith. His wife, joint holder of one account, claimed to know nothing about the activity.
The civil action: recovery of undue payment before the Court of Torre Annunziata
Why sue the account holder
After filing a criminal complaint with the Public Prosecutor, supported by an OSINT report and a blockchain analysis, we brought civil proceedings under the simplified procedure (Articles 281-decies et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure). The claim was for recovery of an undue payment under Article 2033 of the Civil Code: whoever receives a payment without legal ground must return it, regardless of good faith, which only affects when interest starts to run.
We claimed over 20,000 euros from the account holder alone, for the sums credited to his own account, and over 13,000 euros jointly from both spouses, for the sums paid into the joint account. Suing the wife too was not an obvious choice, but joint ownership of the account makes her a recipient of the payment as well.
The strength of this approach is confirmed by two recent judgments our firm obtained before the Court of Florence, ordering money mules to repay the full amount even in good faith, and by our similar case on recovering scam money through an Article 2033 claim.
From lawsuit to negotiation
At the first hearing, in October 2026, the judge set the deadlines for the supplementary briefs provided by the simplified procedure. It was at that stage, with the defendants in the proceedings and the risk of a full judgment against them now real, that room opened for negotiation. The result was the agreement of 3 November 2026.
What the settlement provides: the clauses that matter
Amount and instalments
A settlement is a contract by which the parties, through mutual concessions, end a dispute that has already begun (Article 1965 of the Civil Code). In our case:
- the defendants undertake to pay 20,000 euros in full and final settlement of all claims made in the proceedings;
- payment is split into four instalments of 5,000 euros, falling due between November 2026 and February 2027;
- our client waives the balance of the claim.
No admission of liability
The defendants pay "while in no way acknowledging themselves liable or indebted". It is a common clause and, from the victim's point of view, an acceptable one: what matters is the money coming back, not an admission of fault that the account holder would never have signed.
The safeguard clause in case of default
This is the most important point. Missing even one instalment entitles our client to pursue recovery of the full amount claimed in court, minus what has already been paid. In other words, the waiver of the balance is conditional on full and timely performance.
This approach ties in with Article 1976 of the Civil Code, under which a settlement can be terminated for non-performance unless the original relationship was extinguished by novation. Stating clearly that the agreement does not extinguish the original claim prevents a debtor from paying one or two instalments and leaving the victim with a weaker title than the one she started with.
What happens to the lawsuit
So as not to waste the pending proceedings, the parties undertook not to file their briefs and to jointly request that the hearing be postponed to a date after the last instalment. Only once payment is complete will the case be abandoned and allowed to lapse under Article 309 of the Code of Civil Procedure, with each party bearing its own costs. If the instalments do not arrive, the case is still there, ready to resume.
Recovering scam money through settlement: when it makes sense to settle with a money mule
Accepting 20,000 euros against a claim of over 34,000 means giving up roughly 40% of the debt. That choice must be justified, and in our case there were three reasons:
- time: a first-instance judgment, even a favourable one, would not have come for several months, and enforcement would have taken longer still;
- solvency: a full judgment against a debtor who cannot pay is worth less than a sustainable agreement paid in instalments;
- certainty: the good-faith defence, though irrelevant to the right to restitution, could affect interest and fuel longer litigation, including on appeal.
There is one point on which we must be clear. The settlement includes the parties' undertaking not to bring further actions, file complaints or join criminal proceedings arising from the facts as civil parties. This waiver concerns the victim's civil rights, but has no effect on criminal prosecution of offences prosecutable ex officio, such as fraud aggravated by the victim's reduced ability to defend herself, or money laundering: the Public Prosecutor remains free to proceed. Anyone signing such an agreement must know this, and anyone proposing it must not present it as a way to "close" the criminal case.
Finally, settling with the account holder does not settle accounts with the real organisers of the scam. The money transferred to the foreign account and converted into crypto remains the subject of the investigation opened by the complaint, including through international cooperation.
Recovering money from an online scam: what to do if it ended up in Italian accounts
If your transfers went to Italian accounts held by individuals, the steps to consider are:
- a complete criminal complaint, listing every transfer and requesting seizure of the funds;
- identifying the beneficial owner of each account;
- a formal demand and an invitation to assisted negotiation;
- a civil claim for recovery of undue payment, possibly preceded by a precautionary attachment;
- assessing, case by case, a settlement with safeguard clauses, where time, costs and the debtor's solvency make it worthwhile.
Even smaller amounts can be recovered, as our case of the YouTube likes scam before the Justice of the Peace shows. No serious professional can guarantee full recovery. But every Italian account the money passed through is a starting point.
Legal assistance to recover money lost to an online scam
Our firm assists online scam victims at every stage of recovery: from the complaint to tracing the flows, from civil claims against account holders to negotiations and settlements, through to enforcement in case of default.
If you transferred money on the instructions of a fake broker or investment platform and want to know whether and how you can get it back, fill in the form at the bottom of this page: one of our lawyers will review your documents and get back to you.
Do you need legal assistance?
Tell us about your case: free assessment, no obligation.
